Which Fish Ponds Are Actually Worth Building?
Almost any fish can live in a pond, and almost every farm stops at one Lava Eel. Turns out three more ponds are real money makers, the famous shard pond is a trap, and your roe is secretly the best thing you can put in a Preserves Jar.
Build FOUR ponds for money, in this order: Lava Eel (about 1,170g a day when full), Ice Pip (~709), Blobfish (~687), and Sturgeon (~665, for caviar). Get each one to 10 fish as fast as you can, age the roe in Preserves Jars, and give your first Golden Animal Cracker to the Lava Eel pond. Everything else is a pretty aquarium, and the Rainbow Trout “prismatic shard pond” takes nearly three in-game years to pay out once.
1How ponds make money
A pond costs 5,000g, 200 Stone, 5 Seaweed, and 5 Green Algae at Robin’s, and it takes up a 5×5 patch of your farm. Every morning it has a chance to make one item, and that chance grows with the number of fish: 23% with one fish, 95% with ten. So a pond with three fish in it is barely working. Your fish are never used up, which means a full pond pays out forever. One catch: if you skip a day, the new item replaces the old one instead of stacking, so swing by on your morning rounds.
- Stock it the day you catch the fish. One fish is enough; they breed every one to five days.
- Do the pond’s quests. At 3, 5, 7, and sometimes 9 fish, the pond asks for an item before it grows again. The Lava Eel asks for Fire Quartz, then Basalt or 2 Diamonds, then 2 Mega Bombs, then an Iridium Bar.
- Expect 45 to 60 days to fill it. Don’t judge a pond by its first month; it is still ramping up.
2The four ponds worth your dirt
Lava Eel is the king, and it isn’t close: about 1,170g per day with the roe aged, which works out to around 47g per tile of land, with no watering and no off-season. But the next three are where most players leave money on the table. Ice Pip (caught on mine level 60) and Blobfish (from the Night Market submarine) both beat the Sturgeon, and both are easier to catch than a Lava Eel, which only bites about 7% of the time in the floor-100 lava. Sturgeon is still worth a slot, since it is the only fish that makes caviar.
Your Lava Eel roe is the BEST thing you can put in a Preserves Jar, period. Aging it adds about 274g per jar-day, which even beats pumpkin pickles. Plan on 2.5 jars per roe pond so they keep up, which means about ten jars if you run all four ponds.
3Ponds that pay you in stuff
Some ponds won’t make you rich, but they make something you can’t easily get anywhere else. Pick these only if you’ll actually use what they make:
- Midnight Squid gives you about one squid ink a day, the only renewable ink in the game.
- Void Salmon gives you void essence and the occasional Void Egg, so you can start void chickens without waiting on the Witch or paying Krobus 5,000g.
- Blobfish pulls double duty: about half of its non-roe items are Farm Warp Totems, plus a 2% shot at a 2,500g Pearl every day.
The Rainbow Trout prismatic-shard pond is the most famous pond tip on the internet, and it is a trap. The shard chance is 0.1% a day, so the average wait is about 2.9 in-game years, and the pond earns a sixth of a Lava Eel the whole time. If you want a shard, go find one in Skull Cavern instead.
4The 1.6 cracker trick
In 1.6, a fish pond accepts one Golden Animal Cracker, and it permanently DOUBLES the pond’s output. On a Lava Eel pond that is worth about 1,170g extra every single day. Pigs still refuse crackers, so your first two should go to ponds (Lava Eel first, then Ice Pip or Blobfish) before any barn animal.
Put ponds on the land your crops can’t use. Beach farm sand breaks sprinklers but ponds don’t care, and awkward corners on any map are perfect. Because ponds need no watering, they keep earning on the days you spend deep in Skull Cavern.
| Pond (10 fish) | Gold per day | Why build it |
|---|---|---|
| Lava Eel | ~1,170g | The champion, and the best jar job |
| Ice Pip | ~709g | Mine level 60, easy to stock |
| Blobfish | ~687g | Pearls and warp totems too |
| Sturgeon | ~665g | The only caviar maker |
| Rainbow Trout | ~163g | Skip it: the shard is a ~2.9-year wait |
Our very serious colleagues at The Gem Sea Journal priced every pond in the game, from the production gate to the jar math to the odds on every lottery ticket. Bring coffee.